tv Sunday Morning CBS February 7, 2016 9:00am-10:30am EST
safe! taking a nap, vick? hey. hey, we need some help here! when we opened his locker and saw the vials, we callelapd. megan: that's very civic-minded of you. unless, of course, this has more to do with the federal grand jury probe into baseball doping. i don't want anyone here accused of hiding anything from the grand jury. and not from the league either. oh, yeah? you know he was juing? no. well, he had put on a bit of muscle lately.
he made video recordings of his swing. mm-hmm. vick johnston. he was drafted by the oakland a's at age 18. for six years, he was one of th a.l.'s top sluggers. and then, for the next two years, he was on and off the dl. finally sent him back down to the minors. according to the coach, this was supposed to be his comeback season. he was determined to make it back to the bigs. so we found these e-mails on his laptop. oh, yeah? we know where they're from? no. not ye so far, tracing the source has been a dead end, but they seem to say that they know he was juicing, and it could, quote/unquote, "ruin your career." so what? blackmail? what's the file attachment? that's why you're here. this math right here, they say, proves that he was using. this is advanced
all right. what? sabermetrics. yeah. baseball math? that's right. and this is way advanced. i mean, this is not the kind of stuff you're going to find in the box scores of the sporting news, you know. i'll tell you that. any way any of that could spot drug use? i don't know. i mean, i'm going to have to figure out what these abbreviations and notations mean. that's not standard math stuff? well, when mathematicians create n types of analyses, they often devise their own notational shorthand. but i love doing research. i mean, maybe i'll find somebody who knows this field. well, the death of baseball player vick johnon was the result of a massive hemorrhage in the brain. he had a stroke? from the damage to the vessels, his blood pressure must have skyrocketed. can steroids cause that? normally, no, but here's the thing. johnston had vials containing a designerteroid: thoracyclene. most contain thoracyclene in a form that's
holds a concentration that's 30 times greater. this strength would cause a catastrophic rise in blood pressure. this was an accidental overdose? no way. thoracyclene is never produced or distributed at this strength. this vial was specially prepared. so it was intended to be lethal? it's hard to see another purpose. so we're looking at murder. captioning sponsored by cbs paramount network television you pay your car insurance premium like clockwork. month
after month. year after year. then one night, you hydroplane into a ditch. yeah... surprise... your insurance company tells you to pay up again. why pay for insurance if you have to pay even more for using it? if you have liberty mutual deductible fund ,
sign up to immediately lower your deductible by $100. and keep lowering it $100 annually, until it's gone. then continue to earn that $100 every year. there's no limit to how much you can earn and th savings applies to every vehicle on your policy. call to
learn more. switch to liberty mutual and you could save up to $509. call liberty mutual for a free quote today at see car insurance in a whole new light.
i have tried so hard to forget what it felt like when someone told me i had colon cancer. we had a follow up cat scan that showed it had gone to her liver. it was pretty intense and we had to move pretty quickly. we needed a second opinion. that's when our journey began with cancer treatment centers of america. one of our questions was, how are we going to address my liver? so dr. litvak had said, "i think we could do both surgeries together," i loved that! to find out more about our treatment options, go to cancercenter.com. our teams of physicians and clinicians are experienced and compassionate bringing
my health is good. cancer treatment centers of america, you have people that really care. they are my family now. these people are saints. they're saints. please call or visit cancercenter.com today. the evolution of cancer care is here. cancer treatment centers of america. care that never quits. appointments available now. somebody gave vick johnston a lethal dose of steroids. so they had to have access to his locker and the thoracyclene. mae the drug company slipped the tainted vial into this supply. so that was the lab. they sd they're going to need more time to identify the manufacturer of the steroid. all right. so, i mean, the question is, why this guy vick johnston?
not bad. yeah. former model, only she's been married for eight years, and her kids are five and two. did charlie get a handle on these equations? yeah. i mean, apparently, he knows a guy. come on. right down the old pipe! nice pitch. yeah. we're just conductin a little hands-on study of the physical properties of the cssic curveball. you know, newton himself was interested in curveballs. i mean, clearly, baseball wasn't invented in his day, but he was fascinated with the way a ball can curve through air. and who wouldn't be? it's all fluid dynamics. oh, yeah. see, air sticks to the surface of the ball, so, when the pitcher puts spin on it, pressure builds up on one side and decreases on the other, and that imbalance, and the ball curves. you know, hitting that pitch is one the hardest feats in all of sports. but, charles, when you called, i think your question had more to do with statistics. yeah. let me show you guys
as you see, dr. waldie, this is high-level sabermetrics, but i just don't know what some of these symbols mean. and you know that i've won the faculty fantasy baseball league two years in a row. i do. and, since fantasy baseball is based on statistics, i figured you'd be into sabermetrics. oh, absolutely. it's the only way to pick a winning fantasy team. how much of our school's supercomputer time is given over to this crunching of baseball stats? i'll never tell. this stuff is pretty wild. very cool changepoint detection. do you recognize the person who might have done this work? give me a little time. if this person is active in fantasy baseball or sabermetrics, i'll find somebody who knows who he is. good. he said people wanted to use him. vick's been under pressure toin all his life. they were all after a piece of him-- coaches, owners, fans. was he particularly close to anyone in the organization? no. coaches and the other players
only what he could do for the team. the only person that really cared about him was his agent, richard clast. yeah, vick trusted him. said he wasn't looking for a quick buck. he was thinking long-term. and wh were vick's prospects? this was the last year on his contract. no other teams were interested in picking him up because he hurt his shoulder, plus the two knee surgeries. he needed to get his game back up. he said the money he made now would need to last us the next 40 years. was there anyone that would have wanted to hurt him? did he have any enemies? no one stood to gain if he died. vick was only valuable if he was playing ball. do you know where he got the drugs?
to them, he was just a piece of equipment. we don't give them steroids, and we don't tell them what drugs to take. but if they use, you benefit. these are grown men. they make their own choices. and, if they don't get caught or busted, you turn a blind eye. we don test players unless the league says we have some reason to. otherwise, we try not to get into hypotheticals. which is never. even when a guy who usually benches 225 is suddenly pushing 350. the team screwed vick. he gives them six great years, he plays through an injured shoulder 'cause they need him for a stretch drive, then he ends up the disabled list. i understand he was working very hard to get back in the majors? yeah. he would have made it, too. these are good. thank you. vick was the real deal.
did you know he was taking steroids? (sighs) he said it was just untile could get his numbers back up. ank you. most players use now and again. i'd say, at any given time, 25% of them. this was about vick's next contract. it was now or never. thank you. some would say that thereis life after baseball. really? what were vick's options? he was drafted out of high school. it wasn't like he had another career he could fall back on. he'd be lucky to get a job making 33k a year coaching some jc team. you met his wife. think she was going to stick around for that? hey, can you just give me one second? i'll be right with you. great. what about his kids? they worshiped their baseball hero father. you think they're going to look up to some used car salesman? i don't know. i thought the wife really seemed to care about him. well, i might be cynical, but i've seen an awful lot of wives move on after the baseball money dries up.
it's my job to take care of my clients, to keep them playing and making money as long as they can. obviously, i have to care about their heth and well-being. but with vick, it was different. he was actually one of my best friends. professor waldie sent out queries, asking fantasy league players if they've seen similar work and this is what we got back. hmm. where'd this come from? a web site called boxscoretimes.com. it's for real stats fanatics. well, just looking at it, i mean it's gotta be the same guy. right? the abbreviations are identical. only here, he explains what they stand for. db-- distance batted. ej-- elevation of trajectory. tb-- thrown bats. thrown bats? who is this guy? oswald kittner. he plays in 16 high-stakes fantasy leagues. kittner. okay. i'm gonna go tell the fbi. now that i know what these abeviations mean, i may be able to determine whether this math really does reveal drug use. so, thank you, gentlemen. someone gave kittner's apartment a going over. we didn't nd the computer.
he's unemployed. we got a 25-year-old high school dropout with no bank accounts, no car, no criminal record. super, neighbors, no one's seen him for a couple of days. might be a blackmail, but if not, his works' definitely involved somehow. incredible. this kittner person has basically reinvented the shiryayev-roberts changepoint detection procedure to pinpoint steroid use. and without the need for medical tests. i mean, this could have mar ramifications. yeah, right, 'cause there's no way to test for drugs like thoracyclene and thg. once they're metabolized in the body, they're undetectable. yeah, the wonders of sabermetrics. it really is a powerful form of analysis in baseball. the physical nature of the game involves chance, so the difference between a hit and an out could be millimeters or milliseconds, so, when you have athletic situations involving chance repeated over and over again, a statistical analysis can isolate and reveal human performance. well, you know, it wouldn't be the first time
in a 1993 article in the american statistician, j. bennett, using sabermetrics, analyzed shoeless joe jackson's career. he was able to prove that jackson played up to his full potential in every one of the 1919 black sox series. so, even though he was accused of throwing the whole series, jacksowas completely innocent, wasn't he? that's right. math restored a man's good name and reputation after 70 years. i find that rather beautiful. but, you know, this doesn't clear the player of cheating; it rather does just the opposite. i know. so, to test if it works, i gathered stats from players generally believed to have used steroids and ran them through kittner's analysis. huh. what did you find? his work seems to be quite accurate. 20 minutes ago, i was on the couch watching blazing saddles in my pajas. this better be good. it's better than good. the red cowgirl s? megan: mm-hmm.
okay, uh... so kittner's equations work. they identify when a player is using perfomance-enhanment drugs. all right, so, even if people thought johnston was using... they couldn't prove it, and now they can with kittner's and kittner could probably even be blackmailing him. that's right, and when charles told me that this kittner person had dropped out of sight, it got me to thinking, displaced people will be drawn to places that meet essential needs. if you're tired, you need a place to lie down. if you're thirsty, you need a source of water, and if you play fantasy baseball, you need the internet. larry: and of special note here: tomorrow is the deadline for the winter fantasy draft. so kittner needs to plug in his laptop. yeah, what's...? that's a downtown address? yeah, that's little tokyo. they have cyber caf\s in the area. larry: well, fortunately, human geography is much less immense than that of the cosmos. colby: you know what this place kind of reminds me of? let me guess. bladerunner.
up! hey. was that really necessary? yeah, it is when you run. hands behind your back! hey, well, wait. are you really fbi? yeah, for real. well, at the risk of me getting beat up, uh, can i ask what you're arresting me for? in your case, skateboarding is a crime. mmm, that smells delicis. thanks, but it's for sandra. i know ... such a shame about will. i'm glad you're doing this for her. i just wish we could do more. she's got a lot on her plate now between william's hospital expenses and his funeral bills. she also lost his pension when he died. it makes me wonder... i've beethinking the same thing. and, you know, sooner or later one of us may end up in the same position. and i think we need to protect ourselves with life insurance. yeah, but at our age and with your health? we don't have that kind of tra money. if we were going to get life insurance,
well, it's not too late. i looked into it. mass mutual has a policy designed to cover the things we would need and it starts at 10 bucks a month. okay, so we can afford it. what about your health? you can't be turned down for health rsons. it's called guaranteed acceptance life insurance. what do you think? i think this is something we need to do. now, if you're age 50-75, it's easy to get reliable coverage at an affordable price. call massmutual today for guaranteed acceptance life iurance. with no medical questions or exams, you cannot be turned dn. with one phone call, you can get coverage ranging from $2,000 - $25,000, and premiums can start at less than $10 per month. guaranteed acceptance life insurance can help your loved ones cover expenses such as funeral costs, remaining medical expenses and credit card bills. you can choose from several convient payment options, and benefits are paid quickly and directly to your beneficiaries.
for more than 160 years, our policyowners have mattered most to us. massmutual's rings are among the highest of any company in any industry. you can feel confident we can help you protect the people who matter most to you with guaranteed acceptance life insurce. call massmutual today at this number.
so before you stick me on the next plane down to guantanamo, can i exercise some legal rights? what, uh, what is this supposed to be? e-mails you sent to vick johnston. what? no way. come on, oswald, i talked to a lot of smart people. they all know your work. well, they're blowing smoke up your skirt. if you were wearing a skirt. anyway, i-i have no idea what this is supposed to be. (groans) well, th, i'll have to ask you the classic-- if you didn't do anything wrong, why'd you run? because last week i came home and two guys were tearing up my apartment. so i got the hell out of there. your beef monkeys come at me on the street. i'm not gonna wait around to see if they're legit. do you know who broke into your apartment or why? well, i win a lot at fantasy baseball. i-i just assumed somebody was trying to sneak a peek at my research. well, it must be a pretty
actually, it is. one of the leagues i play in, winner gets 15 grand. 15 grand inspires a little b&e. so... me and my laptop went off the grid. this is dr. charles epps. he's a professor of mathematics up at calsci. him? yeah. him. well, then, maybe he can elain all this stuff to you, 'cause all these, these numbers, i-i, it's over my head. it's funny. i don't think it is. it's oddly similar to this work, which you posted on a basebalstats web site under your own name. he's the only person using these abbreviations, and it works. his analysis accurately spots steroid use. good will hunting. yeah, you got me, all right? yeah, this is my work, and that is exactly what it does, but, i never e-mailed it to vick johnston. i never showed this to anybody. why? why didn't you?
it's a snificant advantage in fantasy baseball-- if nobody else knows about it. tech went through his laptop. it's not the source of the e-mails that johnston received. yeah, see, i mean, i don't see a motive. i mean, even if he was blackmailing him. which i doubt. he was genuily surprised to see his work on those e-mails. yeah, but what about the break-in at the apartment? it could be they were after his steroid analysis. that still doesn't tell us who gave vick johnston a lethal dose of thoracyclene, though. we know yet where they were manufactured? no, still waiting. all right. we just gotta get a handle on this kid. you know, i don't see him opening up to any of us, but... he might with someone else. um... dr. epps, i got your message. yeah, how you doing, oswald? why don't you follow me in my office. yeah. all right. so, you know,
that your attorney would tell you that i called. oh, yeah. no, he doesn't want me talking to y he thinks you're just gathering information for the fbi. yeah, 'sll-- he right. but the fbi just wants to know who knows about your work. that's all. well, i mean, like i already told them, nobody else knows. there is another reason i wanted to talk to you. um, your analysis is amazing. really. it's deep. it's deep? (laughs) wow. um... deep's good, right? deep-- yeah, complex. elegant, yeah. that's, well... i guess you would know. um... this sff is all calculus, right? yeah. guess you studied calculus in high school, right? oh, no, no, we didn't have it in my school. no, i learned from, like, library books, uh, stuff other fantasy leaguers did. so you're self-taught? i guess so.
you ever think about coming to a place like this to actually study math? well, yeah, but... i mean, dude, i don't even have a g.e.d. dude, you don't even need one. no, seriously, you could get admitted on the strength of your work alone. you should at least consider publishing your findings. oh, hell, no. i gotta keep my best stuff secret. i mean, that's how i win. science is about sharing knowledge. one more reason i'm not a scntist. yeah, you are. you come up with theories, you test them, you make new findings. well, maybe i'll have to dust off a shelf for my nobel prize. (scoffs) hi. oh, hey, pop. you know where charlie is? yeahhe's in school. oh, listen, i had two meetings cancel on me this afternoon. yeah. you want to play? yeah, i wish. i can't. i-i gotta, i gotta deal with this case. oh, yeah. the ballplayer. yeah.
he left a wife, two kids. you have any idea who killed him? no, i can't figure out a motive. maybe blackmail, but... the thing is, blackmailers rarely kill, so... what? hmm? what are you doing? nothing. i just... my last year with the rangers, i hit .228 with 36 rbis. with steroids, i woulda hit .260 with 50 ribbbies. so my backup did. the guy winds up in the majors, you know? uh, that would be cheating. yeah, i mean, is it cheating if everyondoes it? yes. we all give up things, donny. yeah? what'd you give up? i don't know. i... one day i was backpacking around europe, no plans, no worries, all the freedom in the world. next thing you know, i got a family
you regret any of it? no. but i do miss the things i gave up for them. all right. so tell uck i'm looking for him. play well. hit 'em long. will do. kittner: fantasy leagues are competitive. i figured if i could come up with a way to spot drug use in players, my trades and drafts would be that much better. how did you figure that? um, players that are juicing are more likely to get injured mid-season. stats back it up. and you're sure you didn't tell anybody about your work? not even my best friends. i mean, i compete against them, you know? you didn't even hint that specific players were doping? players that nobody else knew that about? oh, man. did colby get that report back? don! megan!
you said you didn't tell anyone. no, i didn't, but i got into an argument with my friend chris bronmiller. huge fan of vick johnston's. oh, and you told him that his hero was using steroids? does he have access to your work? well, we hang out a lot, and i always leave my laptop around. (pounding on door) chris bronmiller, we have a warrant. open the door! bronmiller's apartment gets broken into and he disappears. no one's seen his for days. just like what happened with kittner. unlike kittner, bronmiller has a car though. think he's living in it? maybe. you know, i've heard of a certain cal sci professor who's been residing in his car lately. fleinhardt?
some women go for the muscles, some go for the brains. bronmiller's car is down here somewhere. lapd was told not to touch it. that's it right there. doesn't seem like he's living in it. raises the question. i hate doing this. oh, that's a relief. something smells. (coughs) (groans) (coughs) looks like we found chris bronmiller. looks like he's been dead for days. (phone beeps)
just take a breath, okay? oh... man. this is so messed up. who... who would do this to him? we don't know. we didn't find his computer, but we're going to need your help here, pal. i-i told you i don't know anything. i don't have a damn clue. all right, all right, just take a second-- get yourself together. how about his e-mail address? uh... um... chris might have used a cyber cafe account, so it's harder to trace. i can make up a list of places that he hung out. that's good. that'll help. chat room cafe in la crescenta. e-mail accounts eated through their server over the last few months. i'm checking for credit card accounts in the name of chris bronmiller. oh, there it is. let me see if i can open some of these file attachments. oh, yeah, hey, this is kittner's work. yeah?
who sent the e-mails to vick johnston. and look at that-- he got an e-mail in response. "regarding your statistical analysis: interesting stuff. "i'd like to meet and talk about it. signed vick johnston. but it wasn't sent from johnston's laptop. i want you to trace it and let us know, okay? sure, i'll try. chris bronmiller thought he was going to meet his baseball hero. yeah, who's dead. hey, you know, we have two guest rooms in the house. are you sure you want to...? no, i'm fine here. i prefer this. i just don't want to go home for a while. not after what happened to chris. right. no, i understand. the fbi still isn't sure who broke into your apartment. i know. so, uh... what the hell is all this? uh, cognitive emergence theory. ah, of course it is. i'm attempting to mathematically model how conscious thought emerges from basic neural functions.
yeah, that's the basic idea. that's nice. um, you don't have any, like, comics, do you? you know what, i do have something that might interest you. it's a baseball thing. uh... my brother don played in the minor leagues. and i kept his stats, so... you might want to take a look at those. stockton rangers! yeah. they were my fantasy minor league team when i was in high school. well, then let me ask yosomething. colby: thanks a lot. appreciate it. finally got the lab results. they name the manufacturer? there's three companies that manufacture thoracyclene. one's in the philippines, one in france, and one right here, in the l.a. area. now the stuff we foundin johnston's locker has the chemical signature to link it up to the local firm. so that proves they manufactured the fatal dose? well, no, it proves they made the original steroid.
don: smells good. all righty. here you go. thanks. here. doesn't your friend in the garage want to come in for a bite? yeah, i offered. he said he's okay. you know, i kind of think he's used to being alone. oh, yeah? fantasy baseball. what a way to make a living. what do you mean? i think a lot of these guys actually end up working for teams, right? it's true. bill james. bill james was a self-taught baseball stats fanatic who published his findings. he now works for the red sox. oswald: hey, charlie... um, oh, i'm sorry. i didn't mean to interrupt. i just wanted to answer charlie's question. that's all right. what question? a baseball question. um, about you, actually. yeah, just if you'd kept playing, would you have made the majors? oswald: so i made two evaluations. one if you had continued to develop normally, and one if you'd decided to use steroids. this should be interesting. um, so with the 'roids, you probably would have raised your batting average to .280
well, so, it sounds like the majors. well, "ish" because, well, yeah, your hitting would have improved-- your overall value as a player would have diminished. why? how so? well, 'cause don's value was as a utility player. you didn't excel at one particular position. you played several very well. you were a solid fielder. quick mentally and physically and steroids would have messed th that. yeah, so, and without the drugs? uh, it's a bit harder to say. um, a lot of major league clubs like to have a few utility guys on the bench-- players who are smart and can adapt quickly to different situations. yeah, like at the fbi. like the fbi. man: brx makes nutritional supplements. vitamins, protein powders. and you manufacture thoracyclene? one of our chemists created it for use in adolescent males with pituitary malfunction. people forget that most steroids and sports enhancement drugs
they're used to stimulate thgrowth of bone marrow, as hormone replacements in males and to treat age-related problems in the elderly. you're the only company in the u.s. that manufactures thoracyclene, correct? we hold the patent here, yes. two foreign manufacturers also pay us a liceing fee for the right to produce it as well. colby: you were originally located in north carolina, but we understand you ran into some troubles there? the attorney general was against holistic medicine. so, we relocated to a state that doesn't have an agenda a against alternative medicine. so you're saying that investigation had nothing to do with your production of steroids? i had a feeling this was where this was going. so, i thought i'd save you a little work. stacy, bring me that file please. our sales records of thoracyclene as submitted to the fda. every purchase was made by a licensed physician or distributor. and the only patients who should be receiving it, are young boys with grow disorders. found a guy who brx sells thoracycne to
dr. thomas mandel. yeah, why him? specializes in sports medicine. apparently treats a lot of college, high school kids. all right, let's check him out. david: 18,19, it's pretty young to start cutting corners. the drugs don't do the work for you, man. they just change your body chemistry so you can work out harder and longer. the things you pick up in college wrestling, you know. yeah, and i admit i was tempted, but the problem is, you start altering your body chemistry as an adolescent, you run the risk of serious, permanent damage. like baldness and erectile dysfunction, premature closure of the growth plates. too much testosterone can kill brain cells. it's not worth it, man. and i didn't even get to gynecomastia yet. it's enlarged breasts in men. aah... you worried about violating doctor-patient confidentiality? it's a college facility that's open to all thstudents and we have the administration's permission to be here. nah. if the good doctor wants privacy,
i have tried so hard to forget what it felt like when someone told me i had colon cancer. we had a follow up cat scan that showed it had gone to her liver. it was pretty intense and we had to move pretty quickly. we needed a second opinion. that's when our journey began with cancer treatment centers of america. one of our questions was, how are we going to address my liver? so dr. litvak had said, "i think we could do both surgeries together," i loved that! to find out more about our treatment options, go to cancercenter.com. our teams of physicians and clinicians are experienced and compassionate bringing you a level of care you won't find anywhere else. my health is good. cancer treatment centers of america, you have people that really care. they are my family now. these people areaints. they're saints. please call or visit cancercenter.com today.
i didn't know vic johnston. i never treated him. easy enough to confirm. just give us a list of the people you did sell steroids to. that's a violation of confidentiality. we have half a dozen athletes who said you never examined them or took a medical history. yet you did supply them with sports drugs. mo of them between the age of 17 and 22. a couple as young as 14. all they had to do was show up, pay and get a shot. if i give you a list of people i sell to, what do you give me? points for cooperation. glove down, monty. come on, you guys. let's pick it up. let's see some hustle. come on. max sheveransky? fbi. need you to come with us, sir. what's this about? vick johnston. we know you were his high school coach. i haven't talked to him in years. you should know a search warrant's being executed for your home,
looks like you already know what we're gonna find. we have witnesses that saw you with vick johnston two months ago. he wanted help. no one was offering him a contract. so you supplied him with thoracyclene? i was the only person he trusted. he called you two days before he died. no? no, i don't remember that. your phone records remember it. you spoke to him once for 36 minutes and once for 47. what about? they play pretty good baseball in federal prisons, you know. (sighs) all right. (sighs) vick said he thought hwas ingotog e bexposed. by whom? he wouldn't say. he just said it was gonna get out. that if he got caught, he'd have to give them my name to the grand jury.
not a soul. not even my wife. what did you do? i didn't know what to do. and then vick died. ah, from drugs you gave him. i don't understand how. it was the same stuff everybody gets. kittner: i can't help thinking that if i hadn't developed a doping formula, chris would still be alive. but that... that's not your fault. actions can have unintended consequences. you know, scientists struggle with that. scientists? all the time. scientific breakthroughs have benefits. i play fantasy baseball. but the ability to conceptualize a solution to a problem, it's what applied mathematics is all about, okay? you have that ability. and you can apply it to other problems. you're a good will hunting man, not me.
whether you like to admit it or not, you do also love mat so brx sold to the doctor, the doctor sold the high school coach and the coach sold to vick johnston? yeah, we totally have the chain of supply, but it's still not telling us which one killed johnston. and we have no link to the murdered fantasy baseball player. and both the coach and the doctor have alibis. when bronmiller was killed, sheveransky was in sacramento and the doctor was in las vegas. wait a minute. only the brx lab could make the lethal dose. you know, you're still welcome in my garage. yeah, i know. don't worry about me. i'll be okay. okay, but oswald, just stay in touch. yeah, of course. (car alarm chirps) (tee gunshots, screaming)
>>that is until one of you clips a food truck, ruining your perfect record. >>yup... now, you would think your insurance company would cut you some slack, right? >>no. your insurance rates go through the roof. your perfect record doesn't get you anything. >>anything. perfect! for drivers with accident forgiveness, liberty mutual won't raise your rates due to your first accident. and if you do have an accident, our claim centers are available to assist you 24/7. for a free quote, call liberty mutual at switch to liberty mutual and you could save up to $509 call today at see car insurance in a whole new light.
that's how we roll here at cal-sci. don thinks that someby wants to get rid of your doping equations and anybody who knows about them. and we are trying to determine just who might have that motive. right. now let me ask you, oswald. are you seeing what i'm seeing? dude, honestly, all i see is a lot of chalk. are the numbers supposed to start glowing at some point? yeah, actually, i have known certain expressions to take on a shimmering quality. ah, so you have. look, i'll tell you who has the greatest motive to bury my work. it's obvious. it's the drug company that mak the juice. it's obvious. well, thank you, ofessor kittner. it only took us hours of value assessment to come up with that conclusion and you're saying it's obvious. hasn't your brother taught you anything about crime? isn't it usually the person who stands to lose or gain the most amount of money? thoracyclene is valuab because there's not test for it. of course, you work
right, and then... there's this. what is this? this is an organizational analysis chart. we're quantifying the links between the elements of this case. and note the drug lab. it's linked to everyone. (garbled radio transmission) copy of oswald kittner's analysis. where'd you find this? i've never seen that before. mr. auster, we've established a chain of purchase that connects you to vick johnston. and this mathematical formula we just found, that's a motive for murder. take a look at that. you printed out the e-mails sent to chris bronmiller that set up a place where he was murdered.
none of this was my idea. whoa! good shot, bobby! beautiful, beautiful! keep that up, we'll get a little bidding war going for you. play wherever you want. richard clast? hi. going over a list of your baseball clients. ran their stats through your boy kittner's system. okay, i don't know what this is. i'm not a mathematician. is that why you gave it to the president of brx labs who's a scientist. he told you what this math could do. yeah, i don't know who that is. really? 'cause your phone number's all over his company records. and almost all your clients are juicing. so there must be a lot at stake for a guy like you, huh? yeah, you know what? for a lot of agents. i think we're finished here. thank you. whoa, whoa, you're not going anywhere. you're the only agent who knew about the math application 'cause your client, your best friend, vick johnston told you. let's go. turn around. get you hands behind your back. i found blood on chris bnmiller's jacket that doesn't match his dna.
let's go. you know, i loved this game just as much as vick did. you're what's wrong with this game. hey. hey, guys, it's okay. it's over. we got him. what? yeah, found a gun at this beach house that matched the bullets that were fired at you. wait. so me almost getting shot at actually helped nail this guy? i just hope he gets what he deserves. my friend chris was a decent guy. oswald, the fbi lab at quantico wanted to know if you'd agree to consult with them on your formula. (chuckles) they want to develop it as an investigative tool. i don't know. my secret doping stats in the hands of the feds? no, of course, yes. i'm joking. whatever you guys want. i owyou. i just feel i should tell you i got a call from vick's minor league team.
okay, but this work for the fbi could be a really great opportunity for you. yeah, look, you can do both. look how overworked this guy is. your work could be recognized. you could even publish an article in the american journal of statistics. my boyhood dream come true. he's got the aptitude and the ability. he just can't see it for himself. hey, you guys see the news? that case of yours is big stuff, n. that's right. we got ourselves a scandal. and if the fbi can prove the efficacy of oswald's analysis, it could get even bigger. yeah. you, uh, thirsty? you thirsty? i'll take a beer. beer? three beers? that case of yours bring back memories, does it? yeah, well, hey, look, you know? it's my first love. firslove, my ass. what are you talking about? don't you remember how you got started in baseball? i always loved baseball. nah, not really. your mother and i got you into little league
to get you stop playing around with that little toy gun that your uncle tommy gave you. oh, yeah. what, that was that silver six-shooter. yeah, yeah, you were playing with it constantly. we didn't think it was very healthy, so we figured baseball would get your mind off it, see, and it did... for a couple of decas. i guess so. yeah, yeah, you love baseball, but it wasn't your first love. hey, don't you remember when you were a kid you used to love to play cops and robbers? donny, you were always the cop. well, then, to donny epps, a born cop. a most excellent one. i say hear, hear, to that. thanks.
you've got to finish this weekend. don't worry. the kids will have a new playground by monday morning. all right, kids. he'll be here all day with that backhoe. now you can watch for a while, but stay back. that's not a backhoe, that's a skid loader. (drilling) a backhoe's bigger. thank you, malik. welcome! trudy! make surthey stay behind the fence. i got 'em, mrs. bell. all right, come on, guys. you can watch him over here. (drilling continues) well, change is good. charlie: not always. let rephrase. change is inevitable and those who adapt most quickly are most likely to survive. yeah, well, you already have tenure.
larry: has our new division chair, mildred, said anything to you? we can protect you. man: ladies and gentlemen, esteemed colleagues and friends. we celebrate the appointment of dr. mildred finch to the physics-math-astronomy division chair. i just want you to know i'm willing to go to bat for you with dr. finch. oh, thanks, charlie. ...means that she speaks your languages. all of them. i give you... dr. mildred finch. (applause) thank you. thank you. i am delighted to be back home with you all. if she has any sense, she'll make u tenure-track. well, she already has. already? tenure? with a higher salary. ...and we will attract young, brilliant minds. we're going to reinvigorate this division, hmm? (applause) now, one of the advantages of having worked here for so long, is that i know where all the bodies are buried, so... (laughter, scattered applause)
oh... change is good. where did dr. fleinhardt get to? oh, he recalled an obligation. congratulations. honestly. do you know how wonderful it is to have a chair conversant in math, physics and cosmology? i mean... well, i intend to encourage a more collaborative spirit among the departments. you know what, i like that. i do. yeah, and collaborationtakes time, charlie, your time. of course. dr. ramanujan, have you considered my offer? i have, and... i would love to work with you on your research. excellent. and you will serve on the curriculum committee. okay. i just... oh, hey. hello. hello. hi. hey. this is dr. mildred finch. she's our new chair. this is my father, alan. millie. hi. millie. nice to meet you. you, too. amita: dr. finch just returned from an 18 month sabbatical in antarctica. really, antarctica? yeah. oh, what were you studying, penguins or ice? actually i insinuated myself into a minor position on amanda, the giant neutrino telescope.
an engineering i was completely ill-suited for. my father's an engineer. i adjusted a dial three times a week. i mainly just went to think in peace. oh. so how did that work out for you? i came back with a strong sense of what's important and what's not. which is... what? not wasting time. (thuds, drills) okay, a few more minutes and then snack time. we want to stay outside. malik, don't you want some cookies? (thuds)
captioning sponsored by cbs paramount network television three children have been pulled from the sinkhole. two remain trapped. the rescued kids and their caretaker, trudy perez, are en route to county hospital. we're awaiting word on their conditions. why are we called in on this? apparently the doj has been investigating kentwell constructio for two years-- bribery, wire fraud, kickbacks, payoffs to cover half-assed work. don: hey. the company all across the western states. big bucks. you guys all remember ausa howard meeks, right? hey. kentwell construction built this school? the playground. ten years ago. my fraud case has languished. hard to pre, hard to get anybody excited about it. unfortunately, now... we have victims? and publicity. we want the fbi to take over the field investigation. i've talked the local da about holding off on any potential homicide charges till we take a shot at these guys.
the older lady, trudy perez, is not expected to make it. so what's the plan? well, as soon as the kids are out, we're gonna go in. let's start with seeing if we can find any negligence on kentwell's part. there is. and what about that guy tearing up the place with a back hoe? local parent doing a good deed. it's not his fault. this has kentwell's fingerprints all over it. you really don't like these guys. yeah, money keeps them above the law, and it pisses me off. i want them in prison, not just paying a fine. i'll start working on finding a construction specialist. my father might be able to help you with that. we should see if we can find out how these guys got the contract to begin with. yeah, they had to deal with someone at the school. it was a favor, man. you volunteered to repave the playground off the books. the pavement was cracked. kids can't play ball on that. you were digging up the old surface. and bam. i've gotta calthe parents. riva! what in the hell were you thinking? you can't order work without school board approval. i have begged for help for years.
school superintendent daria sampson. special agent sinclair. the old lady died. trudy? (helicopter hovering) (siren wailing) this isn't asphalt. it's too brittle. it's shattered like a windshield. i have no idea what this is. hey! did they get the children out? megan: um, the last two boys were inside the structure when it went down, so they' buried, and the structure's really unstable, so it's moving kind of slowly. alan: were they able to talk to the kids? one, but he's getting weak. alan, we need to know if this sinkhole could occur naturally. or if it's from faulty construction. well, sinkholes are rare in california. it's the wrong geology. the chances are that this was triggered by altering the underground water flow.
meeks: damage control has arrived. what? kentwell? their attorney, reed parkman. he's been legally obstructinmy case from every direction for two years. very inventive guy. how you doing there? mr... parkman? how are you? so i'm gonna need a copy of blueprints from that playground all right? i need, uh... geology reports... environmental... the whole works. i've got a subpoena. no problem. if kentwell has any culpability, they'll make it right. like they've done in the past, good citizens that they are. did they rescue the last boy yet? actually, they think he's unconscious, so they haven't been able to find him. are those parents from the school? i'd like to talk to them. no contact with the families. you're not gonna buy them off. wouldn't dream of it. my clients want to express their concern and support. what, no one from kewell's coming down here? they've instructed me to cooperate fully. i bet.
for a jury this time, reed. i'm going to want a copy of that report asap. all right. fair enough. larry: the magical element of water peneates the impenetrable like a sleeping mind dreams the solution to a problem. can you hand me that map? you know, water not only moves around rock, it actually flows right through it. nature haso much to teach us. you know, it's possible that the construction company caused a slow drainage of the aquifer, that then created an underground cavn which became the sinkhole. or water eroded limestone over a thousand years and this was the day, the hour, the very minute of catastrophic failure fated for eons. i like that. mildred: larry, i've been looking for you. actually, i was just on my way out to... to...? to, do, um, just office hours. on saturday?
to send you an invitation for my reception and we were flummoxed to discover we have no home address for you. larry: i think just e-mail is best. yeah, all right, you know what, larry? where you live, that's up to you. that is your business and i respect your privacy. good, because privacy is important to me. unless... you're living in the steam tunnels. you know, we used the steam tunnels to play dungeons and dragons when i was an undergrad, oh, yeah? yeah. but it seems that someone has set up house down there. which is no good. it's a liability. so i'm going to seal the steam tunnels, larry. i see. good. okay, have a very good weekend. you too, sir. he's living in the steam tunnels? i didn't say that. but maybe you should check and make sure he's okay. yeah, of course. he was kind of staying with us,
groundwater flow? not high-end math. a case for my brother. you know what? we're going to have to tighten up in that area, as well. tighten up? yes. teamwork, charles. all right? i needou to take more responsibility here in this department, and spend less of your time on your forensic puuits, clear? mildred... you will chair the phd admissions committee. congratulations. i don't haveime for that. not a request, my friend. mr. shabaz, it won't be long. they think they can get him out pretty soon. okay. is there anyone else you'd like me to call for you? maybe someone that can meet you at the hospital? my wife's flying in from a business trip to chicago. you have the whole city pullin for malik right now. if we make it through this, i'm getting him out of here. out of los angeles?
you guys show up for a big disaster, but tomorrow we're on our own again. we got classrooms with no books, teachers have to provide toilet paper and pencils. kids get sick with mental illness, birth defects, cancer. malik has a growth on his spine. now the doctor's telling me not to worry, but children shouldn't have tumors on their spines or get trapped in 20 foot hellholes. man: coming up. coming up. we got him. easy, easy, get it back. what going on in this place?
i have tried so hard to forget what it felt like when someone told me i had colon cancer. we had a follow up cat scan that showed it had gone to her liver. it was pretty intense and we had to move pretty quickly. we needed a second opinion. that's when our journey began with cancer treatment centers of america. one of our questions was, how are we going to address my liver? so dr. litvak had said, "i think we could do both surgeries togeer," i loved that! to find out more about our treatment options, go to cancercenter.com. our teams of physicians and clinicians are experienced and compassionate bringing you a level of care you won't find anywhere else. my health is good. cancer treatment centers of america, you have people that really care. they are my family now. these people are saints. they're saints. please calor visit cancercenter.com today. the evolution of cancer care is here. cancer treatment centers of america. care that never quits.
charlie: listen, kentwell construction is trying to snow you guys with these meaningless blueprints and reports. so there's got to be a smoking gun in here somewhere. look, we got some new files. something one of the dads said is really bugging me about a lot of sick kids. how are those little boys doing?
but the prognosis is good for both of them. you know, i cannot figure out this paving material. i think i read something about that. okay, there's two cases of leukemia at the school now, and three cases in children who attended in the past. charlie, what are the odds of this many cancers in a small school? meg, do me a favor. i need you on these new boxes please. you guys are going to make me get up, aren't you? megan: but it's a lot of leukemia. you're talking about cancer clusters-- statistically rare. more likely, this a case of texas sharp shooting. say there's a guy who's never held a gun before and he aims at the side of a barn and he shoots. when he's done, he draws a circle around the closest shots, ignores the other and he declares himself... a texas sharpshooter. right. and cancer clusters are just like that. people over-interpret the evidence. don: all right, here we go. the stuff they used to pave with appears to be patented. it's patented? may i? yeah. it's actually made from recycled materials. huh. here. charlie: tce's, heavy metals, perchlorates.
what? that is toxic waste. no. is that legal? put it down. charlie: well, the patented process supposedly makes it inert. but it's new, so... hold on. you're saying this stuff is actually breaking down? larry: eroding substrate, creating a sinkhole. megan: causing cancers. so much for the texas sharpshooter. david: you signed every contract between kentwell construction and the school board. i sign a lot of contracts. miss samson, were you aware that the stuff they use for the pavement is made from toxic waste? meeks: toxic waste? we had epa clearance, it's harmless. you knew about it? it's irrelevant. is it also irrelevant that you lease a vacati home from from kentwell on catalina island for a few hundred dollars a year? i came in here to help. if you're accusing me of something, speak to my attorney. wait, wait, hold on. how long have you had an attorney?
david: when we connect you to this, you'll be on the hook for trudy perez's death and the injury to those children. megan: how is malik doing? his surgery went well. he won't be awake for another few hours. my wife is with him. um, all these parents have sick kids? this school has lots of neurological disorders as well as cancers. learning disabilities, behavial problems. it's all documented. is this related to the playground caving in? all the kids who fell in have rashes. what's going on? we don't know, but that's why we asked you to bring all these folks here. hey, everyone. thank you for coming. charlie: you seen larry? no, not this weekend. hey. do you want to have dinner with me tonight?
are you dr. eppes' personal assistant? at his beck and call 24/seven, as they say? what? nice. that's not fair. i see that you've been on the supercomputer for... well, a while now, so i have to de-prioritize your job. is this an fbi case? we're working with odds ratios. you know what? it's all right, amita. yes, it is an fbi case. we're analyzing childhood cancers, birth defects and neurological deficits related to a potentially toxic material. so... well, it now low priority on the server. dr. finch, the supercomputer is the only way to analyze large data sets quickly for proper comparison. i have sympathy for the families, charlie, i do. i nursed my father through cancer, i don't take it lightly. but i'm also aware that the person who could discover the cure for ccer may be one of our students who would benefit greatly from the use of this computer, not to mention the attentions of professors eppes and ramanujan. charlie: not one student
to the contrary... there are many ways to contribute to improving the world, charlie. charlie: excuse me. we'll take this up again, mildred. millie. i don't appreciate being disrespected, especially in front of a colleague. thenou might want to behave more like a colleague. i beg your pardon? you're dating your thes professor. you dress like a kid. sorry, i didn't realize there s a dress code. amita, you have the most promising career of any of the faculty hires. i just want you to have the major career that you are capable of. i appreciate that. you need to redefine yourself as a professor, and not a grad student. an individual, not some appendage of charlie epps. okay, well, thanks for clearing that up. which means taking your own research more seriously than you take his.
katie was in kindearten during construction, 1994. she was always on the swings, loved tumbling, said she was going to the olympics. my wife noticed the tumor at a gymnastics tournament. neuroblastoma. megan: and what year was she diagnosed? '99. i'm not sure if it was the chemo that killed her or the cancer. miss reeves, who did this? what's going on here? i don't know, mr. bowden, but i'm going to try and find out. all right, what do you got? matheson elementary has a substantial elevation of cancer and neurological deficit rates compared to the national average. right. and? e normal background rate is, like, one incident, of let's say leukemia, in every 10,000 kids. matheson has seven times that frequency.
yeah. this is a statistical map of pediatric toxicology in l.a. county. each dot represents one sick child. blue is for aml-- acute myelogenous leukemia. red are for neurological disorders. green are birth defects. to me this is a much bigger problem than kentwell, right? it would seem that way, but take a look at this. these are schools in l.a. county with playgrounds paved by kentwell. no way. don, we don't have one, we have 17
you pay your car insurance premium like clockwork. month after month. year after year. then one night, you hydroplane into a ditch. yeah... surprise... your insurance company tells you to pay up again. why pay for insurance ifou have to pay even more for using it? if you have liberty mutu deductible fund , you could pay no deductible at all. sign up to immediately lower your deductible by $100. and keep lowering it $100 annually, until it's gone. then continue to earn that $100 every year. there's no limit to how much you can earn and this savings applies to every vehicle on your policy. call to learn more.